Breaking Amish Season 4: Brooklyn Episode 3 Bright Lights, Big Sinners ( Air Date 2014-10-02 ) Genre Documentary category. Overview "Temptations abound as a group of young Amish explore life beyond their Amish culture. Ultimately, they will make the biggest decision of their lives – to remain Amish/Mennonite or become English and face the consequences of being shunned by their family and friends.".