It’s Olaf’s birthday and the girls decide to take him to Lazarus Island to celebrate. Pat and Aish get separated from Olaf and Steph, who end up on St. Johns Island. Steph goes to look for the girls while Olaf wants to get a taste of the sea. Olaf has a miserable birthday – he goes skinny dipping and gets stung by a goldfish, bullied by two young boys and baked in the sun. The girls who have had a good day – finally meet Olaf and try to make it up to him.