Man v. Food Season 4 Episode 1 New York City, NY ( Air Date 2017-08-07 ) Genre Reality category. Overview "The show's new host, Casey Webb, takes on the NY City's Pick Your Poison Challenge (150 ounce milkshake, 8 pound Sloppy Joes or 6 habanero ghost chilly wings). He also tries the fondue burger and pizza topped with pizza inside a pizza.".